Award-Winning for a Reason. Apple Annie's Famous Chocolate Chip Cookies. Soft, rich, and the perfect ratio of chocolate chips; absolutely delicious.
$2.75
Lemon Delight
Sweet lemon cake cookie with a balanced sour punch; the perfect ratio of the two, topped with a lemon-sugar drizzle. Delicious all year around, but especially delightful during the warmer months.
$2.75
Marshmallow Cherry Chip
Our newest flavor released in 2024 at our dedicated cookie bakery in Martinsburg, WV. This cookie was previously only available at this one location; however, now it is available nationwide! A specialty cookie that is rich in flavor and ultra soft and pillowy to the bite, topped with a white chocolate drizzle: it is truly the perfect cookie.
$2.75
Oatmeal Raisin
Just like Grandma used to make them… soft with the perfect balance of cinnamon and baked oatmeal. The perfect cookie for whenever… but especially great for breakfast time!
$2.75
Peanut Butter
Old Fashioned like grandma use to make it; soft, peanut buttery, with the perfect ratio of cane sugar and caramelized brown sugar, added in pinch of salt and forked with our classic railroad tracks design, this cookie isn’t just called old-fashioned for no reason, it lives up to its name.
$2.75
Peanut Butter Surprise
Peanut buttery cookies with Reese’s cups & candy pieces, and rich peanut butter chips; altogether making this a classic fan favorite cookie.
$2.75
Salted Caramel Pretzel
Caramel & Pretzel Crunch with a Soft Center; Delicious Every Time.
$2.75
Strawberry
Seasonal strawberry is our classic cake cookie recipe with flavorful strawberry notes. This cookie is a go-to in the summer when you want something sweet, but something lighter and refreshing in taste. Topped with a sweet shine made strawberry glaze, this cookie is bound to become your new favorite cookie. Get them now while they’re in season… they won’t be around for too long.
$2.75
Sugar
Classic sugar cookies made the old-fashioned way: premium granulated cane sugar, high-quality flour, and an extra pound of butter making for a balanced sweet and buttery taste in every bite. These cookies are a staple will keep you wanting more.
$2.75
Triple Chocolate
Fudgey, chocolatey, decadent; all with a rich soft center. This cookie is packed with semi-sweet chocolate morsels; but don’t let that fool you, it still remains finely balanced with the perfect amount of salt and butter, making for a cookie that tastes just like an ultra indulgent brownie! A popular cookie in the bakery, and the kind that will keep you coming back for more.
$2.75
White Chocolate Cranberry
The perfect balance of dried fruit and white chocolate chips, chocked into our famous almond base cookie dough. A wonderfully delicious cookie that’ll keep you coming back for more.
$2.75
Cookie of the Week: Trail Mix
🥜🍫Salty & Sweet — the best combo! Introducing our newest cookie of the week: Trail Mix! 🍎Made for travelers everywhere… know somebody hitting the road here soon? Ship them the gift of Apple Annie’s cookies to keep them feed along the way! 🌲🪵Hitting up a hiking trail sometime soon? Bring with you the perfect snack-sized energy booster!
